Laws And Ordinances


1511-1515



We have seen how Diego Columbus suspended Ponce in his functions as

governor ad interim, and how the captain after obtaining from the

king his appointment as permanent governor sent the Admiral's nominees

prisoners to the metropolis. The king, though inclined to favor the

captain, submitted the matter to his Indian council, which decided

that the nomination of governors and mayors over the islan
s

discovered by Christopher Columbus corresponded to his son. As a

consequence, Ceron and Diaz were reinstated in their respective

offices, and they were on their way back to San Juan a few months

after Ponce's final success over the rebellious Indians.



Before their departure from Spain they received the following

instructions, characteristic of the times and of the royal personage

who imparted them:



"1. You will take over your offices very peaceably, endeavoring to

gain the good-will of Ponce and his friends, that they may become

your friends also, to the island's advantage.



"2. This done, you will attend to the 'pacification' of the Indians.



"3. Let many of them be employed in the mines and be well treated.



"4. Let many Indians be brought from the other islands and be well

treated. Let the officers of justice be favored (in the distributions

of Indians).



"5. Be very careful that no meat is eaten in Lent or other fast days,

as has been done till now in la Espanola.



"6. Let those who have Indians occupy a third of their number in the

mines.



"7. Let great care be exercised in the salt-pits, and one real be paid

for each celemin extracted, as is done in la Espanola.



"8. Send me a list of the number and class of Indians distributed, if

Ponce has not done so already, and of those who have distinguished

themselves in this rebellion.



"9. You are aware that ever since the sacraments have been

administered in these islands, storms and earthquakes have ceased. Let

a chapel be built at once with the advocation of Saint John the

Baptist, and a monastery, though it be a small one, for Franciscan

friars, whose doctrine is very salutary.



"10. Have great care in the mines and continually advise Pasamonte

(the treasurer) or his agent of what happens or what may be necessary.



"11. Take the youngest Indians and teach them the Christian doctrine;

they can afterward teach the others with better results.



"12. Let there be no swearing or blasphemy; impose heavy penalties

thereon.



"13. Do not let the Indians be overloaded, but be well treated rather.



"14. Try to keep the Caribs from coming to the island, and report what

measures it will be advisable to adopt against them. To make the

natives do what is wanted, it will be convenient to take from them,

with cunning (con mana), all the canoes they possess.



"15. You will obey the contents of these instructions until further

orders.



Tordesillas, 25th of July, 1511.



F., King."



It is clear from the above instructions that, in the king's mind,

there was no inconsistency in making the Indians work in the mines and

their good treatment. There can be no doubt that both he and Dona

Juana, his daughter, who, as heir to her mother, exercised the royal

authority with him, sincerely desired the well-being of the natives as

far as compatible with the exigencies of the treasury.



For the increase of the white population and the development of

commerce and agriculture, liberal measures, according to the ideas of

the age, were dictated as early as February, 1511, when the same

commercial and political franchises were granted to San Juan as to la

Espanola.



On July 25th the price of salt, the sale of which was a royal

monopoly, was reduced by one-half, and in October of the same year the

following rights and privileges were decreed by the king and published

by the crown officers in Seville:



"1st. Any one may take provisions and merchandise to San Juan, which

is now being settled, and reside there with the same freedom as in la

Espanola.



"2d. Any Spaniard may freely go to the Indies - that is, to la

Espanola and to San Juan - by simply presenting himself to the

officials in Seville, without giving any further information (about

himself).



"3d. Any Spaniard may take to the Indies what arms he wishes,

notwithstanding the prohibition.



"4th. His Highness abolishes the contribution by the owners of one

'castellano' for every Indian, they possess.



"5th. Those to whom the Admiral grants permission to bring Indians

(from other islands) and who used to pay the fifth of their value (to

the royal treasurer) shall be allowed to bring them free.



"6th. Indians once given to any person shall never be taken from him,

except for delinquencies, punishable by forfeiture of property.



"7th. This disposition reduces the king's share in the produce of the

gold-mines from one-fifth and one-ninth to one-fifth and one-tenth,

and extends the privilege of working them from one to two years.



"8th. Whosoever wishes to conquer any part of the continent or of the

gulf of pearls, may apply to the officials in Seville, who will give

him a license, etc."



The construction of a smelting oven for the gold, of hospitals and

churches for each new settlement, the making of roads and bridges and

other dispositions, wise and good in themselves, were also decreed;

but they became new causes of affliction for the Indians, inasmuch as

they paid for them with their labor. For example: to the man who

undertook to construct and maintain a hospital, 100 Indians were

assigned. He hired them out to work in the mines or on the

plantations, and with the sums thus received often covered more than

the expense of maintaining the hospital.



The curious medley of religious zeal, philanthropy, and gold-hunger,

communicated the first governors under the title of "instructions" did

not long keep them in doubt as to which of the three - the observance

of religious practises, the kind treatment of the natives, or the

remittance of gold - was most essential to secure the king's favor. It

was not secret that the monarch, in his private instructions, went

straight to the point and wasted no words on religious or humanitarian

considerations, the proof of which is his letter to Ponce, dated

November 11, 1509. "I have seen your letter of August 16th. Be very

diligent in searching for gold. Take out as much as you can, and

having smolten it in la Espanola, send it at once. Settle the island

as best you can. Write often and let Us know what happens and what may

be necessary."



It was but natural, therefore, that the royal recommendations of

clemency remained a dead letter, and that, under the pressure of the

incessant demand for gold, the Indians were reduced to the most abject

state of misery.






Until the year 1512 the Indians remained restless and subordinate, and

in July, 1513, the efforts of the rulers in Spain to ameliorate their

condition were embodied in what are known as the Ordinances of

Valladolid.



These ordinances, after enjoining a general kind treatment of the

natives, recommend that small pieces of land be assigned to them on

which to cultivate corn, yucca, cotton, etc., and raise fowls for

their own maintenance. The "encomendero," or master, was to construct

four rustic huts for every 50 Indians. They were to be instructed in

the doctrines of the Christian religion, the new-born babes were to be

baptized, polygamy to be prohibited. They were to attend mass with

their masters, who were to teach one young man in every forty to read.

The boys who served as pages and domestic servants were to be taught

by the friars in the convents, and afterward returned to the estates

to teach the others. The men were not to carry excessively heavy

loads. Pregnant women were not to work in the mines, nor was it

permitted to beat them with sticks or whips under penalty of five gold

pesos. They were to be provided with food, clothing, and a hammock.

Their "areytos" (dances) were not to be interrupted, and inspectors

were to be elected among the Spaniards to see that all these and

former dispositions were complied with, and all negligence on the part

of the masters severely punished.



The credit for these well-intentioned ordinances undoubtedly belongs

to the Dominican friars, who from the earliest days of the conquest

had nobly espoused the cause of the Indians and denounced the

cruelties committed on them in no measured terms.



Friar Antonia Montesinos, in a sermon preached in la Espanola in 1511,

which was attended by Diego Columbus, the crown officers, and all the

notabilities, denounced their proceedings with regard to the Indians

so vehemently that they left the church deeply offended, and that same

day intimated to the bishop the necessity of recantation, else the

Order should leave the island. The bishop answered that Montesinos had

but expressed the opinion of the whole community; but that, to allay

the scandal among the lower class of Spaniards in the island, the

father would modify his accusations in the next sermon. When the day

arrived the church was crowded, but instead of recantation, the

intrepid monk launched out upon fresh animadversion, and ended by

saying that he did so in the service not of God only, but of the king.



The officials were furious. Pasamonte, the treasurer, the most

heartless destroyer of natives among all the king's officers, wrote,

denouncing the Dominicans as rebels, and sent a Franciscan friar to

Spain to support his accusation. The king was much offended, and when

Montesinos and the prior of his convent arrived in Madrid to

contradict Pasamonte's statements, they found the doors of the palace

closed against them. Nothing daunted and imbued with the true

apostolic spirit, they made their way, without asking permission, to

the royal presence, and there advocated the cause of the Indians so

eloquently that Ferdinand promised to have the matter investigated

immediately. A council of theologians and jurists was appointed to

study the matter and hear the evidence on both sides; but they were so

long in coming to a decision that Montesinos and his prior lost

patience and insisted on a resolution, whereupon they decided that the

distributions were legal in virtue of the powers granted by the Holy

See to the kings of Castilla, and that, if it was a matter of

conscience at all, it was one for the king and his councilors, and not

for the officials, who simply obeyed orders. The two Dominicans were

ordered to return to la Espanola, and by the example of their virtues

and mansuetude stimulate those who might be inclined to act wickedly.



The royal conscience was not satisfied, however, with the sophistry of

his councilors, and as a quietus to it, the well-meaning ordinances

just cited were enacted. They, too, remained a dead letter, and not

even the scathing and persevering denunciations of Las Casas, who

continued the good work begun by Montesinos, could obtain any

practical improvement in the lot of the Indians until it was too late,

and thousands of them had been crushed under the heel of the

conqueror.



* * * * *



King Ferdinand's efforts to make Puerto Rico a prosperous colony were

rendered futile by the dissensions between the Admiral's and his own

partizans and the passions awakened by the favoritism displayed in the

distribution of Indians. That the king took a great interest in the

colonization of the island is shown by the many ordinances and decrees

issued all tending to that end. He gave special licenses to people in

Spain and in Santo Domingo to establish themselves in Puerto Rico.

In his minute instructions to Ponce and his successors he regulated

every branch of the administration, and wrote to Ceron and Diaz: " ...I

wish this island well governed and peopled as a special affair of

mine." On a single day (February 26, 1511) he made, among others of a

purely private character, the following public dispositions: "That the

tithes and 'primicias'" should be paid in kind only; that the

fifth part of the output of the mines should be paid only during the

first ten years; that he ceded to the colony for the term of four

years all fines imposed by the courts, to be employed in the

construction of roads and bridges; that the traffic between San Juan

and la Espanola should be free, and that this island should enjoy the

same rights and privileges as the other; that no children or

grandchildren of people executed or burned for crimes or heresy should

be admitted into the colony, and that an exact account should be sent

to him of all the colonists, caciques, and Indians and their

distribution.



He occupied himself with the island's affairs with equal interest up

to the time of his death, in 1516. He made it a bishopric in 1512. In

1513 he disposed that the colonists were to build houses of adobe,

that is, of sun-dried bricks; that all married men should send for

their wives, and that useful trees should be planted. In 1514 he

prohibited labor contracts, or the purchase or transfer of slaves or

Indians "encomendados" (distributed). Finally, in 1515, he provided

for the defense of the island against the incursions of the Caribs.



If these measures did not produce the desired result, it was due to

the discord among the colonists, created by the system of

"repartimientos" introduced in an evil hour by Columbus, a system

which was the poisoned source of most of the evils that have afflicted

the Antilles.



More

;