Responsible Government

The period of responsible government in Canada

dates from the union of 1841; in Nova Scotia, from 1848; in New

Brunswick, the same year; in Prince Edward Island, 1851. The agitation

for responsible government, from its very nature, cannot be limited to

an exact period. It was a gradual growth, whose roots ran back almost to

the beginning of the period of British rule in Canada. The Quebec Act of

1774, the Constitutiona Act of 1791, the Ninety-Two Resolutions of

1834, the Rebellion of 1837, and Durham's Report, were mile-stones on

the road to responsible government. =Index=: (William Lyon Mackenzie era) Rattray on, 5, 6; Lord

John Russell on, 19, 20; resolution refusing, passed by Imperial House,

20; Lord Glenelg opposes, 21; Erskine May's review, 21; Bond Head on,

22; Lord Durham justified in demanding, 61, 67-69; the "true remedy,"

61, 63; Durham's Report favours, 81; Mackenzie urges, 81; Mackenzie

advocates, 148, 166, 177, 244, 279; Seventh Report on Grievances, 273;

Lord Glenelg on, 279-286; Lord Russell opposes, 325; comes at last, 409;

May on value of, 490. (Sir John A Macdonald era) Its principles accepted in Act of Union in

1840, 17, 22; established under Elgin, 32-33; principles of, outlined by

Lord Grey in despatch to Sir John Harvey, 47-50. (Wilmot era) History of movement

for, in New Brunswick, 99-130. (Lord Sydenham era) Effects of its introduction

foreseen, 81; not fully understood, 82, 107; idea opposed in reports of

committees of both Houses of Upper Canada Legislature, 100-103;

Sydenham's great tact in dealing with question of, 104; limited views of

its more ardent advocates, 105, 230; open to theoretical objections,

105-107; advocated by Hincks and Howe, 107; problem not theoretically

solved, 108; responsible government favoured by French-Canadians, 117;

opposed by English element in Lower Canada, 117; favoured by Reform

party in Upper Canada, 117; agitation on subject of, 124; Sir George

Arthur opposes, 125; inhabitants of Gore district pass resolutions in

favour of, 125; Lord John Russell's despatch on the subject, 169-172;

misunderstood by Conservatives and Reformers alike, 172, 173, 219, 230;

absence of, in Canada, 175, 176; Russell's despatch on tenure of office

brings it nearer, 184; the sole issue on which Reformers were united,

185; could be introduced only gradually, 189; not clearly defined in

Durham's Report, 223; Sydenham's view of, 224; excitement on the subject

diminishing, 225; unity in the Cabinet a necessary condition of,

227-229; question of, in Nova Scotia, 257-264; French-Canadians

indifferent to, 305; appreciation of, in Upper Canada, 305; resolutions

on, adopted by Legislative Assembly, 310, 311. (George Brown Era) Explained in the

Banner, 9; Durham's remedy for political unrest, 12; withheld by

Metcalfe, 20-25; introduced by Elgin, 33, 35; Hincks's and Morin's

services in cause of, 67; George Brown's views on, 67. (Sir Georges E. Cartier era) La Fontaine's

fight for, 97; Lord Elgin's good work for, 98. (Joseph Howe era) Fight for, in Nova

Scotia, 18-19, 30-31; only partially conceded by Union Act of 1841, 53;

triumph of, in Nova Scotia, 111; in Canada, 111; Sir John Harvey on,

112-113; Joseph Howe's fight for. See Howe. (Baldwin / La Fontaine / Hincks era) Baldwin's "one idea,"

ix; the corner-stone of the British Imperial system, ix; evolution of,

in Canada, ix; impossible in early days of British rule, 1-2; Head calls

it the "smooth-faced insidious doctrine," 38; the desire for, at the

root of both constitutional and armed movements in Canada, 52;

recommended by Durham, 56-58; advocated by Hincks in the Examiner, 58;

Union Bill identified with, by Reformers of Upper Canada, 61; Sydenham's

views on, 64-67; favoured by La Fontaine, 70; discussion on, in

Legislature of 1841, 90-95; the Baldwin resolutions, 108-110; history

of, 137-143. See also Brown, George; Howe, Joseph; Baldwin, Robert;

Hincks, Sir Francis; La Fontaine, Sir L. H.; Elgin, Earl of; Head, Sir

F. B.; Sydenham; Metcalfe; Bagot; Durham; Stanley; Papineau, L. J.;

Cartier, Sir G. E.; Ninety-Two Resolutions; Twelve Resolutions;

Representative government; Constitutional Act, 1791; Union Act, 1840;

British North America Act, 1867; Mackenzie, W. L.; Union of 1840.